
So another season ends in disappointment for future Hall of Famer Brett Favre.
When he announced his first retirement 2 years ago I thought it was a pretty wise decision on his part.
When he decided later in the summer of 2008 to come out of retirement, I thought it was perhaps the most foolish decision of his entire career.
Two years on I looked over some thoughts I wrote about Brett Favre’s ongoing saga back in ‘08.
Was I right? Or has Brett proven that his decision to return was in fact the right one?
Here are my ‘08 thoughts:
In the interest of full disclosure, let me first say, I root for the Steelers and the Broncos and that’s pretty much it. But like many other football fans the world over, probably minus division rival fans in Minnesota and Chicago, it’s almost impossible to be a fan of the game and NOT be a fan of Brett Favre.
To date, he has been a Pro football player for 17 years. That’s a crazy number in the modern NFL, especially for a Quarterback, and to play 16 of them for the same team in the world of free agency is virtually unheard of.
Statistically speaking……he leads in so many different categories, it’d take a whole show to name ‘em all….so I won’t….but in a nutshell….
Brett Favre has thrown 442 touch down passes, for over 61 thousand yards and won 160 regular season games as a starter…. All of which are more than any other Quarterback in NFL history. He’s appeared in 9 pro bowls..and is the ONLY 3 time AP Most Valuable Player in history…. And maybe the most telling statistic of all, Brett Favre started 253 consecutive regular season games dating back to 1992….and that’s something you can’t do unless you love the game..I mean LOVE the game…plain and simple.
And as is the case with all the “great ones”, there were a lot of things to love about watching Brett Favre play the game other than his statistics.
He had a unconventional throwing motion that didn’t always result in perfect spirals….he played on instinct a lot of the time and ball protection wasn’t exactly his strong suit…..and though he didn’t scramble often, when he did it looked like he was running uphill in a windstorm…..but Brett Favre was a great improviser and was often at his best AFTER a play broke down. And he was a little bit wild …you never knew exactly what he was going to do…….but he’d do anything to win the game for his team. That much is beyond debate.
In the world of modern sports, where so many athletes squander their gifts on the temptations offered by money and stardom and ego, everything about Brett Favre indicated that other than his family, there was NOTHING more important to him than playing football.
In addition to the last minute heroics and the rocket passes released from his golden right arm, there were struggles, as there would be in any career that lasts 17 years. He wrestled with an addiction to pain killers and issues with alcohol…..and what fan could ever forget the Monday Night game in 2003 when he passed for 4 touchdowns and nearly 400 yards in the game only one day after his father Irv died suddenly of a heart attack.
As all football fans know, a tearful Brett Favre announced his retirement from the game in March of this year…. several months after taking his Packers to within minutes of an appearance in Superbowl 42.
But then, earlier this month, the rumors started. Brett Favre wanted to return to football……he says rushed his decision to retire and was ready and willing to play again.
But the Packers had already named Aaron Rodgers their starting Quarterback for the season. Brett Favre made it known that he wouldn’t play back up to anybody so he asked for the Packers to release him unconditionally. Unsurprisingly, they wouldn’t. That’d be like asking the United States to release George Washington……..it just ain’t gonna happen.
Green Bay GM Ted Thompson has hinted that he would trade Favre OUTSIDE the NFC North in exchange for adequate compensation but that deal hasn’t really found legs yet. And to be fair, who can blame Ted Thompson? As bad as it would be for Packer nation to see Brett Favre wearing another team’s jersey, it would be worse yet to have to play him twice a year in that jersey when he’s starting for a division rival like the Vikings or the Bears.
To call it a no win situation at this point would be the understatement of the century.
The BRING BACK BRETT t-shirts have already flooded the state of Wisconsin. How’d you like to be Aaron Rodgers or Ted Thompson right about now?
Brett Favre turns 39 in October and has said if the Packers won’t give him back the starting job then he would prefer to play for Minnesota or Chicago.
He is eligible for the hall of fame in 2013…and regardless of what happens in the coming weeks, he’s a guarantee 1st ballot entry. Somewhat awkwardly, the Packers are already scheduled to retire his #4 jersey at a ceremony at Lambeau Field on September 8.
Most of us can’t even imagine what it must be like to be a professional athlete of the highest caliber and to have to admit it’s time to quit playing the game you love. But from the perspective of a football fan who doesn’t have a lot personally invested in whether Brett Favre plays again, I gotta say….it’s time to hang ‘em up, Brett. It’s time.
Could you win some more games as an NFL Quarterback? Yeah…of course you could.
Could you still lead a team to the Superbowl? Statistically speaking, it’s not all that likely…but stranger things have happened in the world of sports.
But if you do come back this season or even next season, whether it’s in a Packer uniform or another…..all it will do is complicate the story of your life’s work and cause turmoil for the team you love, and the fans you love, both of whom have loved you unconditionally in return….and will continue to do so.
You’ve had a brilliant career. One of the best the game has ever seen. You played the game with passion, dignity and respect. Everything about your style of play reminded us that no one man is bigger than the game itself. And as hard as it probably is to do, it’s time to say good-bye to the game in the same way, Brett.
As a football fan….thanks for the memories. I mean that sincerely.